Comparison¶
There are several good ways to get AI review on GitLab merge requests. Here's an honest look at where this project fits.
| ai-code-review-gitlab-plugin | GitLab Duo Code Review | CodeRabbit | PR-Agent (Qodo, open source) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| License / cost | MIT, free (you pay your LLM) | Paid GitLab add-on | SaaS, paid plans | Open source (AGPL) |
| Runs where | Your GitLab runners | GitLab | Vendor cloud | Self-hosted or vendor |
| Bring your own model | Bedrock, Anthropic, Gemini, OpenAI-compatible, Ollama | Limited | No | Yes (many providers) |
| Setup | One CI job / one include |
Enable the add-on | Install app | Webhook server or CI job |
| Inline line comments | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
| Custom prompts from S3 / repo | ✅ | – | Config-based | Config-based |
| Footprint | <1,000 lines of TypeScript, single CLI | – | – | Large Python project with many tools |
When to choose this project¶
- You want something small and auditable that your security team can read in one sitting.
- You're on AWS and want reviews to go through Bedrock in your own account.
- You want a CI-native job with no extra server, webhook service or SaaS app.
- You need air-gapped reviews with a local model via Ollama.
When to choose something else¶
- You want chat-style interaction on the MR (
/ask,/improvecommands), auto-generated descriptions and many other tools: look at PR-Agent or CodeRabbit. - You're already paying for GitLab Duo and want a first-party, zero-setup experience: use Duo Code Review.
Feature details for other products change often. Check their own documentation for the current state, and open an issue if something here is out of date.